Showing posts with label Graphic Novel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Graphic Novel. Show all posts

Thursday, May 13, 2010

American Born Chinese

Title- American Born Chinese

Author- Gene Luen Yang

ISBN-1596421520

Publication Information- First Second, 2006


 

Plot Summary- This story covers two tales that eventually converge. The main story is Jin's attempts to assimilate in a nearly all white school; interlaced throughout is the story of the Monkey King. The Monkey King desires to be more than he is because he is denied entrance to a party of the gods. As he learns more and more, he changes both physically and spiritually until he is nearly human physically, but rude and arrogant. He tries to usurp the gods themselves. He is trapped for 500 years under a pile of rocks to learn patience and when he is finally allowed to escape, it is only by transforming back to his natural form and letting go of his power. Jin is starting at a new school where he has no friends. As time goes by, he eventually meets Wei- Chen and they quickly become friends. Both find they are interested in girls and attempt to make different relationships work, but when Jin kisses Wei-Chen's girlfriend, their friendship is ruined. That night Jin dreams of becoming someone different and wakes up as Danny, a white boy. Every year, Danny's life is ruined by the arrival of his cousin who forces him to consider who is really is and what he really wants.

Critical Evaluation- Although initially confusing, this graphic novels comes together nicely at the end with a good moral for all of us- be who we are born to be and life will be easier. Jim's life is doubled in the parable of the monkey king and the two stories come together at the end and we realize the monkey king is a real entity. What is best about this book is that also addresses issues of stereotyping, of relationships, and family obligations. It packs a heavy punch in a small amount of space. The artwork of the novel is simple but emphasized the issues of assimilation and stereotyping quite well. This was the first graphic novel nominated for a National Book Award and to win the Michael L. Printz award.

Reader's Annotation- When Jin is forced to start at a new school with no other Chinese students, he is scared and out of place. Wei-Chen arrives and his life changes in ways he could never imagine.

Author Information- Yang is a teacher at a Roman Catholic school in San Francisco and has written and published several comics in the last few years. He began writing them when he was in elementary school. The book does have some autobiographical elements. Yang was forced to befriend a recent immigrant who spoke little English. The experience forced him to confront issues of social identity early in life.

Curricular Ties- none

Genre- graphic novel, coming of age

Book talking ideas- How does race affect our identity? What is the message of these two stories?

Challenge issues- Racism, crude humor.

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age-13-16

Why I selected this piece- Librarian recommended

Frankenstein

Title- Frankenstein (Graphic Novel)

Author- Michael Burgan – based on Mary Shelley

ISBN- 1598898302

Publication Information- Stone Arch Classic Fiction, 2008


 

Plot Summary- This is the graphic novel version of the novel is fairly true to the original story, but much shorter. Young Victor is enamored of the natural world and drawn to science. After the untimely death of his mother, he seeks out a way to stop death itself. Although he unable to find that, he does discover a way to reanimate a dead body. However, once he accomplishes that, he realizes that he's made a terrible mistake and drives the creature away. The creature find that he is rejected by humanity time and again and resolves that Frankenstein will make him a mate or he will die too. Victor refuses and the monster starts to destroy all that Victor holds dear. The story culminates aboard a ship where Victor tells his story to Walton.

Critical Evaluation- For many students the original text is unapproachable. The language and syntax is complex and drives many interested readers away. The graphic novel format gives students a much simpler version to contend with. The story is true to the novel, but cuts out or abbreviates characters and scenes. Nevertheless, the important elements, character and theme, are present. Readers still get all the good information from the story that makes them literate in the story and meaning behind references to the Frankenstein myth. While I still recommend that strong readers attack the original, I would highly recommend it to reluctant readers or students interested in the classics but afraid of the initial challenge.

Reader's Annotation- Just because you can do something does not mean you should. Victor Frankenstein discovers the horrors of this truism in the classic story of a scientist gone mad.

Author Information- Burgan wanted to be a teacher but realized that it wasn't a good idea and turned to writing. He has written dozens of books, mostly non-fiction social studies books for reluctant readers. His novels are usually geared to boys who are not interested in the traditional novels. These books include accounts of popular figures like The Rock and a series of historical accounts of wars and countries.

Curricular Ties- English

Genre- Graphic Novel, Science fiction

Book talking ideas- Who is the real monster of the story? What obligations do we have to our creations?

Challenge issues- unlikely given the classic nature of the story, but perhaps some religious objections.

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 13-18- depending on reading level

Why I selected this piece- I teach Frankenstein with my advanced students and have used similar versions with general students but without the pictures. I love the story and students are always interested in it.

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Pride of Baghdad

Title- Pride of Baghdad

Author- Brian K. Vaughan

ISBN -1401203140

Publication Information- Vertigo, 2006


 

Plot Summary- Pride is the story of the lions that escaped the Baghdad zoo during the war. In this case the story is told from the point of the pride, two females, one male, and one cub. The eldest of the three, a female Safa remembers life before the zoo as harsh and unforgiving where she was raped by male lions and scarred by them for fighting. The youngest female has virtually no memory and wants her freedom from the 'keepers' or humans. As they debate the issue, the zoo is destroyed by American bombs and they find themselves freed whether they want it or not. They begin to wander but are driven into the cities by a string of tanks. Once inside the town, they see the devastation firsthand. They become increasingly hungry. After a terrible battle with a bear used for animal fights, the pride stumbles across American soldiers.

Critical Evaluation- This anthropomorphic tale of the effects of war on these animals is both a good tale of the true story of the lions that escaped and were eventually killed by American soldiers as an act of mercy and a critique of the nature of war on those who are innocent. The pride's instincts have been dulled by their captivity for all those years, and they are surrounded by forces they cannot explain. They are surrounded by death and destruction and try to make sense of it. The characters all have interesting character backgrounds: Safa, who knows the dangers of the wild and likes the safety of the zoo; Noor ,who vaguely remembers freedom but never understood the difficulties; Zill, who never had to do anything hard and remembers only the beautiful sunsets and the cub, who is completely innocent. The last page is perhaps the most poignant noting that "there were other casualties as well." Overall, it tells the reality of war from a very different perspective.


 

Reader's Annotation- During the invasion of Baghdad, a group of lions escaped the zoo. This is their story.

Author Information- Brian Vaughan is a varied and talented writer. He began his career as a main line comic book writer with stories like Batman and X-Men, but has also written some of the most famous independent style comics including Y: the Last Man and Ex-Machina. Interestingly, he was also a screenwriter for the television series Lost for three years.

Curricular Ties- History

Genre- Graphic Novel, War

Book talking ideas- How do the lions symbolize people in Baghdad? How do Noor and Safa's conflict reflect the nature of soldiers?

Challenge issues- Graphic violence, rape

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-18

Why I selected this piece- Library recommendation

Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda

Title- Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda

Author- Jean Stassen

ISBN-1596421032

Publication Information-First Second, 2006


 

Plot Summary- This is the story of a young Hutu who loses his mind as the Rwanda genocide destroys the people he cares about and he is forced to comply with his countrymen and also kill people. Deogratias, which means "thanks be to God" is a teenager who has feelings for two Tutsi sisters and a developing drinking problem. As the story moves back and forth in time from before the genocide, during, and after, we see the deterioration of this boys mind as the dogs destroy him. Over the course of the story, he attempts to save the girls and other Tutsis but instead witnesses their brutal rape and murder. He poisons several people that he believes are responsible for the genocide and eventually is arrested.

Critical Evaluation- The brilliance of this novel comes at the expense of your heart. Nothing about the genocide is spared in the text. The language is vulgar but accurate, and the violence is horrific. As a person who remembers the film footage of the genocide, it is a fair artistic representation of history. They great symbol of the story is the protagonist's degeneration into a dog. He knows that what he and others did was horrifically wrong and the dogs that feast on corpses during the genocide symbolically feast on his sanity. Graphically, he becomes the dog as the story progresses. This is not a novel for the faint of heart. For students not familiar with the genocide, there is a very well-written introduction by the translator that summarizes the history behind the conflict.

Reader's Annotation- The story of one boy's descent into hell as his country destroys itself.

Author Information- There is very little about the author available. He was born and raised in Belgium and currently lives in Rwanda. His books have been translated into many languages and he does his own artwork for the story.

Curricular Ties- History

Genre- Graphic novel, war

Book talking ideas- When does a person choose to take a stand against injustice? How does the author use the metaphor of the dog to describe Deogratias's state of mind?

Challenge issues- language, very violent depictions of war and rape. Honestly, were it not that this is based on a real genocide, I'm not sure I could defend it.

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-adult

Why I selected this piece- Librarian recommendation, and I teach a unit on Night that culminates in a research paper on another genocide.

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Blankets

Title- Blankets

Author- Craig Thompson

ISBN -1891830430

Publication Information- Top Shelf Productions


 

Plot Summary- The story takes place of several years, perhaps a decade or more in which we follow the life of Craig. Craig and his brother live in a fundamentalist Christian household with a father that is borderline abusive. Craig has no friends at school to support him and finds solace in only two things, art and religion. However, in high school at a Christian camp, he meets Raina, a reject herself. The two experience love for the first time. Eventually, she leaves him and he finds himself lost in the world again, not knowing where he should go to college or what he should focus on while there. As he continues to read his Bible, he notices contradictions and problems that he cannot reconcile and finds that religion holds no focus for him any longer either.

Critical Evaluation- This is one of those brilliant graphic novels that make the entire genre worthwhile. It will easily take its place amonst others like Maus and Sandman as the year's progress. This is a semi-autobiographical look at Thompson's early life. It is a coming of age story at its core. The art of the novel beautifully reflects the state of mind of the character and perhaps the author at that point in his life. All of it is tied together by the motif of a blanket. At the beginning it is the blanket he shares with his little brother in bed and later the blanket Raina makes for him that with which he cannot bear to part. Most importantly though, is the thematic issues of the story. How does one manage to navigate the minefield of adolescence and not come out crippled as an adult in some way? Clearly we do not. We carry those emotional issues with us long into adulthood. Thompson is perhaps able to exorcise his demons in the process of writing this novel.

Awards


 

Reader's Annotation- What happens to a teenager who can't connect with family or friends?

Author Information- The novel is largely autobiographical so his life is fairly clear upon reading it. After these years, he began working for Darkhorse Comics, a major comic book publisher, but turned to his own work after tendonitis forced him to retire. All of his graphic novels have won several critical awards. He uses very French stylized art instead of the traditional graphics of the comic book industry.

Curricular Ties- Religious studies, English

Genre- Graphic novel, Coming of Age

Book talking ideas- What problems does Craig find in his religion as the years progress? How do blankets play a central role in the story?

Challenge issues- Religious fundamentalists will object to this book based on the portrayal of churches and church functions; sexual content; violent images

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-18

Why I selected this piece- This was recommended to me by my school librarian as an excellent graphic novel that did not involve heroes or fantasy.

Hatter M: The Looking Glass Wars

Title- Hatter M: The Looking Glass Wars Vol. 1

Author- Frank Beddor

ISBN - 97809818737

Publication Information- Automatic Pictures Publishing, 2008


 

Plot Summary- This is a graphic novel story that is peripheral to The Looking Glass Wars novel by the same author. In that text Alyss, the daughter of the Queen of Hearts escapes being assassinated by her Aunt Redd by fleeing into 1850s London. There she is taken in by a family and tells her story to Lewis Carroll, who gets it all wrong. All the while her guardian, Hatter Madigan is searching for her. In this graphic novel, the focus is entirely on Hatter's search for her throughout the streets of London. Hatter has a unique hat that, in the right hands, transforms into a series of blades that can attack or defend as necessary. He is relentless in his search for Alyss because it was the Queens final request that he protect her. In the opening volume, the readers are introduced to the characters, the back story (in case you have not read the novel) and his first adventure to find her. He follows the faint trace of imagination, the critical component of Wonderland, which the princess will exude. He follows the trace of a young girl who has been kidnapped.

Critical Evaluation- Graphic novels are interesting reads. This novel is a spin-off of another series that is, of course, a spin-off of the Alice in Wonderland stories. However, Beddor makes the story much darker in the graphic novels. Reading the source novels would be very helpful although the flashbacks in the text make it not completely necessary. Hatter is a fascinating character that is very different from his Alice in Wonderland counterpart. Alyss, however, is similar to her opposite. Readers should be aware that this story is very violent and the artwork can be disturbing in places. The Looking Glass Wars is listed for pre-teens, but this is graphic enough to make it a better choice for older students. The art, by Ben Templesmith is excellent though if the violence is not an issue for you. Fans of the novel will not find any new material here, but it is a nice addition.

Reader's Annotation- What if Lewis Carroll was wrong? What if Alice came OUT of Wonderland instead of going in?

Author Information- Frank Beddor is a truly interesting man. He has produces films including There's Something About Mary and Wicked and is the CEO of his own film production company, which is the same group that published the graphic novel. He has created a full line of merchandise to go with the original novel series, including the graphic novel, a card game, and a role-playing game.

Curricular Ties- English

Genre- Graphic Novel

Book talking ideas- Is Hatter a good guy or a bad guy? How does the graphic novel compare to the novel? To Alice in Wonderland?

Challenge issues- Violent content, including a torture scene of sorts, fantasy content.

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 12-17

Why I selected this piece- The story was recommended to me by one of my sophomores after the class talked about Alice in Wonderland.