Showing posts with label Historical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Historical. Show all posts

Saturday, May 15, 2010

Of Mice and Men

Title- Of Mice and Men

Author- John Steinbeck

ISBN -0140177396

Publication Information- Penguin, 1983 (my version)


 

Plot Summary- This is the classic story of George and Lennie. Lennie is mildly retarded and gets the pair in trouble in every place they stop to work in the Depression era California farms. He is particularly enamored of things that are soft to the touch, a dress, a puppy, a dead mouse; it does not matter, but once he is touching it, he does not want to let go. George is his cousin and caretaker. While life would be easier for him without Lennie, he secretly treasures having a real friend in a world where most people have no one. After fleeing their last job because of Lennie, the pair find themselves at a new farm. George makes new friends but keeps a watchful eye out for Lennie. Unfortunately Lennie and the farm owner's son Curly do not get along. Lennie ends up crushing Curly's hand and making a permanent enemy. Later Curly's wife finds Lennie petting yet another dead animal and ends up being killed by him accidently. Curly sets out on the hunt.

Critical Evaluation- This is one of my favorite Steinbeck novels (is there a bad one?). Students like this novel because of the overwhelming theme of friendship. Friends in this novel are treasured and cared for in good times and in bad. Furthermore, Steinbeck's ability to describe the Central Valley is so clear that many of my students have good ideas of where these scenes could take place. Students can usually identify with at least one of the characters in the novel; they even feel great sympathy for Lennie. The tragic death of Candy's dog foreshadowing the ending of the novel touches readers nearly all the time. The secondary concern of racism, which in this novel is still tied closely to friendship, is still a timely theme to discuss and students are often drawn to Crooks as a rejected person. All in all, this is a profound story that stays with readers for years to come.


 

Reader's Annotation- In the Great Depression the most important thing to have is a real friend- that and the ability to dream.

Author Information- John Steinbeck is one of the giants of American literature and winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature. He grew up in the Salinas area where this novel is set and knew the countryside and farming community intimately. He also worked frequently with non-fiction. He followed a family during the Great Depression across Route 66 and into California. This trip became the basis for Grapes of Wrath later. He wrote The Moon is Down during World War II, which helped to bolster the Norwegian resistance movement and worked as a news correspondent during both this war and the Vietnam War in which his two sons served. His books are amongst the most studied and banned by schools throughout the nation today.

Curricular Ties- English, Social Studies

Genre- Historical Fiction

Book talking ideas- Would you have taken the same actions as George at the end of the story? How does Steinbeck use animals to reflect the behavior of the characters?

Challenge issues- Racism and language

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-18

Why I selected this piece-. I love this piece, and it is the most cited novel by our seniors in the books I enjoyed survey at the end of the year.

The Book Thief

Title- The Book Thief

Author- Marcus Zusak

ISBN -0375842209

Publication Information- Alfred Knopf, 2007


 

Plot Summary- We start this tale as death tells us about the book thief and his meetings with her throughout her lifetime. The first of these is the tragic death of her little brother. Death does not like to pay attention to the living because they are too heartbreaking. Instead he focuses on the brilliance of the colors around him, but Liesel Meminger calls his attention and he is riveted by her. Liesel's father is taken from them in Austria because he is a Communist, though Liesel does not understand why, and her mother disappears too, but not before leaving her with a foster family who agrees to take her at great risk to themselves. Liesel finds a new family with her foul-mouthed "mother" and kind father. Her habit of stealing books is interesting because she is unable to read them until her foster father teaches her to read in the middle of the night. Liesel becomes friends with Rudy who is obsessed with the German Olympics and Jesse Owens performance there. As the story progresses, the Nazi influence becomes stronger and more dangerous for everyone in the neighborhood.

Critical Evaluation- The book is marketed in the US as a young adult novel, but was sold in Australia, its country of origin, as an adult novel. The book is riveting for any audience. This book is brilliant, if for no other reason than the point of view of the story. It is told by Death, who is clearly irritated that he is fascinated by the life of this young book thief. The characters are intriguing and very realistic. As a teacher of the holocaust, this book is inspiring for the courage of an average family to take in multiple people that the Nazi party is hunting. Thus, the moral of the story- to do what is right even at great peril to one's self, is communicated too. There are several motifs and symbols that weave their way through the story. All in all, it is among the best novels I have ever read on the Holocaust.

Awards

2006 - Commonwealth Writers Prize for Best Book (South East Asia & South Pacific)
2006 - Horn Book Fanfare
2006 - Kirkus Reviews Editor Choice Award
2006 - School Library Journal Best Book of the Year
2006 - Daniel Elliott Peace Award 2006 - Publishers Weekly Best Children's Book of the Year
2006 - Booklist Children's Editors' Choice
2006 - Bulletin Blue Ribbon Book
2007 - Boeke Prize
2007 - ALA Best Books for Young Adults
2007 - Michael L. Printz Honor Book
2007 - Book Sense Book of the Year
2009 - Pacific Northwest Young Readers Choice Master List

Reader's Annotation- Each person finds different ways to survive the impossible. For Liesel it was stealing books during her time with her foster family in World War II.

Author Information- Part of this story is biographical from his grandmother's experiences in a small German town. She witnessed the other side of Nazism, the side that objected and hid families to save them. He knew he wanted to tell that story. At the age of 32, Markus Zusak has penned several novels and established himself as a gifted writer. The novel was intended to be a small book, 100 pages or so, but after three years of working, became much longer and clearly much better.

Curricular Ties- History, English

Genre- Historical fiction

Book talking ideas- What is the effect of Death as the story-teller/narrator? How are colors important in the story?

Challenge issues- Violence, language

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-18

Why I selected this piece-.I teach the holocaust to students every year, and I'm always on the lookout for good novels in this vein. This is one of the very best of the books I've seen.