Showing posts with label War. Show all posts
Showing posts with label War. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Pride of Baghdad

Title- Pride of Baghdad

Author- Brian K. Vaughan

ISBN -1401203140

Publication Information- Vertigo, 2006


 

Plot Summary- Pride is the story of the lions that escaped the Baghdad zoo during the war. In this case the story is told from the point of the pride, two females, one male, and one cub. The eldest of the three, a female Safa remembers life before the zoo as harsh and unforgiving where she was raped by male lions and scarred by them for fighting. The youngest female has virtually no memory and wants her freedom from the 'keepers' or humans. As they debate the issue, the zoo is destroyed by American bombs and they find themselves freed whether they want it or not. They begin to wander but are driven into the cities by a string of tanks. Once inside the town, they see the devastation firsthand. They become increasingly hungry. After a terrible battle with a bear used for animal fights, the pride stumbles across American soldiers.

Critical Evaluation- This anthropomorphic tale of the effects of war on these animals is both a good tale of the true story of the lions that escaped and were eventually killed by American soldiers as an act of mercy and a critique of the nature of war on those who are innocent. The pride's instincts have been dulled by their captivity for all those years, and they are surrounded by forces they cannot explain. They are surrounded by death and destruction and try to make sense of it. The characters all have interesting character backgrounds: Safa, who knows the dangers of the wild and likes the safety of the zoo; Noor ,who vaguely remembers freedom but never understood the difficulties; Zill, who never had to do anything hard and remembers only the beautiful sunsets and the cub, who is completely innocent. The last page is perhaps the most poignant noting that "there were other casualties as well." Overall, it tells the reality of war from a very different perspective.


 

Reader's Annotation- During the invasion of Baghdad, a group of lions escaped the zoo. This is their story.

Author Information- Brian Vaughan is a varied and talented writer. He began his career as a main line comic book writer with stories like Batman and X-Men, but has also written some of the most famous independent style comics including Y: the Last Man and Ex-Machina. Interestingly, he was also a screenwriter for the television series Lost for three years.

Curricular Ties- History

Genre- Graphic Novel, War

Book talking ideas- How do the lions symbolize people in Baghdad? How do Noor and Safa's conflict reflect the nature of soldiers?

Challenge issues- Graphic violence, rape

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-18

Why I selected this piece- Library recommendation

Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda

Title- Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda

Author- Jean Stassen

ISBN-1596421032

Publication Information-First Second, 2006


 

Plot Summary- This is the story of a young Hutu who loses his mind as the Rwanda genocide destroys the people he cares about and he is forced to comply with his countrymen and also kill people. Deogratias, which means "thanks be to God" is a teenager who has feelings for two Tutsi sisters and a developing drinking problem. As the story moves back and forth in time from before the genocide, during, and after, we see the deterioration of this boys mind as the dogs destroy him. Over the course of the story, he attempts to save the girls and other Tutsis but instead witnesses their brutal rape and murder. He poisons several people that he believes are responsible for the genocide and eventually is arrested.

Critical Evaluation- The brilliance of this novel comes at the expense of your heart. Nothing about the genocide is spared in the text. The language is vulgar but accurate, and the violence is horrific. As a person who remembers the film footage of the genocide, it is a fair artistic representation of history. They great symbol of the story is the protagonist's degeneration into a dog. He knows that what he and others did was horrifically wrong and the dogs that feast on corpses during the genocide symbolically feast on his sanity. Graphically, he becomes the dog as the story progresses. This is not a novel for the faint of heart. For students not familiar with the genocide, there is a very well-written introduction by the translator that summarizes the history behind the conflict.

Reader's Annotation- The story of one boy's descent into hell as his country destroys itself.

Author Information- There is very little about the author available. He was born and raised in Belgium and currently lives in Rwanda. His books have been translated into many languages and he does his own artwork for the story.

Curricular Ties- History

Genre- Graphic novel, war

Book talking ideas- When does a person choose to take a stand against injustice? How does the author use the metaphor of the dog to describe Deogratias's state of mind?

Challenge issues- language, very violent depictions of war and rape. Honestly, were it not that this is based on a real genocide, I'm not sure I could defend it.

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- 15-adult

Why I selected this piece- Librarian recommendation, and I teach a unit on Night that culminates in a research paper on another genocide.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

Fallout 3

Title – Fallout 3

Author- not applicable

ISBN- not applicable

Publication Information- Bethesda Game Studios


 

Plot Summary- Fallout takes place in the year 2277, 200 years after the destruction of the world by nuclear war. The player's father has mysteriously left vault 101 and gone into the greater Washington DC area, now known as the Capital Wastelands. The player is suspected in his father's escape and is forced to leave too to find his father to determine why he left. Over the course of the game, the player meets the Brotherhood of Steel and the Enclave and has to determine who is good and who is bad, and, of course, what happened to his father.

Critical Evaluation- This game has won multiple awards because like Bethesda earlier games, it has an open format for player actions. Like Dragon Age, how the game progresses is based upon earlier actions by the players because loyalties can shift depending on actions that are completed. The particularly violent (but entertaining) element of the game is the ability to target parts of a bad guy. One of the criticisms of the games is the shortness of the main quest line, but there are many more hours of play available in different quests and they sent out multiple add-ons to the game. There is a moral quality to the game. Characters may choose to be good guys or be bad guys as the storyline moves along. Each choice has repercussions later in the story although the basic outcome of the story remains the same (as a bad guy, you can nuke an entire town). I have never played the evil side, nor has my husband, but it is an option. It's also a little weird seeing all the hallmarks of Washington DC in nuclear shambles.

Reader's Annotation- You have lived your whole life in the safety of Vault 101, but when your father inexplicably leaves, you choose to see the real world for the first time.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYZpR51XgW0


 

Author Information- Not applicable

Curricular Ties- not applicable

Genre Video game, science fiction

Book talking ideas- not applicable

Challenge issues- not applicable

Interest Age- 15-adult. Truly, this is an adult game, but is played by many teenagers despite the graphic violence

Why I selected this piece- It is an interesting game. My husband bought it at the urging of one of my teenage boys who loves it.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Title- Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Author- Infinity Ward

ISBN Not applicable

Publication Information- Activision


 

Plot Summary- An extension of the Call of Duty series, Modern Warfare 2 is a first person shooter video game. These kind of games are difficult to summarize because they are part of a long series. Essentially, PFC Joseph Allen is recruited into an elite anti-terrorist force, Task Force 141, run by General Shepherd. However, in his first mission as an under-cover insurgent he is killed. The bad guys, Russian Ultranationalists set him up to be the fall guy sparking a war between the United States and Russia that engulfs the entire world. Over the course of events, the two main characters, Captains Price and McTavish learn that Shepherd is the true mastermind of the war- not the Russians- because he believes that a full scale war is good for the world. Price and McTavish decide they can only trust each other and eventually track and kill Shepherd.

Critical Evaluation- The storyline of this game only account for a small fraction of the playing time of this game. From a story perspective, it is convoluted and confusing. As a player, you cycle through 5 characters as they discover different elements and either die or move onto other areas. However, the real playability of this game comes in the multiplayer aspect. There are different forces you are assigned to and different games to play, including Free-For-All, Search & Destroy, Demolition, Sabotage, Domination, Team Deathmatch, and Capture The Flag. In each game, players earn points that unlock new weapons and abilities. Most players race through the storyline or skip it altogether to play online with their friends. The game is kept fresh by being able to download additional content in the forms of maps. My personal play on this game is limited because I cannot play console games, but I have watched my husband play literally hundreds of hours on this game with his friends (and some of my students). It is easily one of the most popular games available right now.

Reader's Annotation- The Russian Ultranationalists are seeking to destroy the United States. It is up to you to stop them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gyASw-1KWyU


 

Author Information- Not applicable

Curricular Ties- Not applicable

Genre- Video Game, War

Book talking ideas- Not applicable

Challenge issues- some groups are upset at the portrayal of their countries, violence, and an easter egg in the game has been challenged as homophobic. However, I would not deal with these issues.

Interest Age- 17-adult but realistically there are many kids younger than that playing

Why I selected this piece- Because it's all my husband plays right now, and many of his online friends are students of mine.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Patrol-

Title- Patrol

Author- Walter Dean Myers

ISBN 0060283645

Publication Information- HarperCollins, New York: 2002

Plot Summary- This is a children's style picture book that is not for young children by any means. The story is one of Myers's poems about Vietnam. It reflects on the land, his platoon, a firefight with air support, an invasion of a village, and the return to his base. The images are in the form of a collage and were created by Ann Grifalconi.

Critical Evaluation- This is a fascinating find. It is rare to have a picture book that is targeted for older children. As a poem, it is worthy of study by itself. The imagery is strong- better than the collage images themselves. The structure is fragmented as one might expect the life of a soldier to be. The poem reflects not only what the soldier would see but what he felt in these situations. He contrasts the beauty of the forest with the fear of death and the sadness of destruction caused by airstrikes. He shows the fear of clearing a village because he doesn't know who the enemy will be in any situation contrasted against the simplicity and quiet of the rice patties.

Reader's Annotation- Miss reading picture books?

Author Information- Walter Dean Myers enlisted in the military at seventeen after dropping out of school

Curricular Ties- History, Art

Genre- War

Book talking ideas- How the art reflect the imagery of the poem? Does the imagery of the poem reflect the realities of war?

Challenge issues- none

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age- The book is designated for 10 and above, but the content makes it more applicable to 13 and above.

Why I selected this piece- I'm always looking for good picture books to use with my students and stumbled across this one for a unit on war poetry.


 

Night

Title- Night

Author- Elie Weisel

ISBN- 0030554624

Publication Information- Steck-Vaughn, New York: 1999.

Plot Summary- Night is the classic semi-autobiographical story of Elie Weisel's experiences in several concentration camps during World War II. Eliezer is a fifteen year old who longs to find a life with God. Instead, he finds his life in a virtual hell on earth with his father. Eliezer and his community do not believe the stories they hear about the treatment of Jews until it is too late. Eliezer's family is first forced into a ghetto and then onto trains and into Birkenau where he is forever separated from his mother and sister. They then end up in Auschwitz and eventually Buna where they witness all the atrocities the Nazis have to offer. As the war comes to an end, he is force marched to Buchenwald, where Eliezer's father dies. Shortly thereafter, he is liberated.

Critical Evaluation- This short novel has always attracted teenagers because of the subject matter alone. Students are often attracted to holocaust fiction largely for the same reasons adults are; we all seek to make meaning of this most horrific period in history. The novel is short and from the perspective of a teenager. Many students come to after reading The Diary of Anne Frank. This piece, however, gives them the story that Anne's diary does not- the life inside of a concentration came from an actual survivor. Furthermore, this novel examines the complex relationship between father and son. In the opening, it is a typical relationship, a stressed one between a teenager and his father. However, as the story progresses, the reader is given the other side of this relationship; the bond that is formed between father and son in extreme circumstances. All in all, this novel is always successful with students and often inspires students to read other pieces in this genre.

Reader's Annotation – Night is the overwhelming story of life inside a concentration camp from the perspective of a young man who actually survived it.

Author Information- Elie Weisel is a world renowned leader in Human Rights and winner of the Nobel Peace Prize. As a survivor, he believes it is his duty to do all that he can to prevent other genocides from happening in the world today.

Curricular Ties- History- holocaust, English

Genre- Historical fiction, holocaust fiction

Book talking ideas- Discuss how the relationship between father and son change throughout the novel. How does one retain faith in the face of ultimate evil?

Challenge issues- This book is rarely if ever challenged.

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA

Interest Age 14 to adult

Why I selected this piece- This is one of my students' favorite novels. It is part of the sophomore curriculum at my school. It is the one piece I never have trouble getting students to read.

Monday, February 8, 2010

Sunrise Over Fallujah

Title- Sunrise over Fallujah

Author- Walter Dean Myers

ISBN- 978-0439916240

Publication Information Scholastic Press: New York, 2008

Plot Summary- Robin Perry, nephew of Richie Perry (from Myer's Fallen Angels) is part of the first wave of soldiers into Operation Iraqi Freedom. Birdy, as he comes to be known by others in his company, enters the military after the attacks of September 11th. However, now as he enters foreign territory, he is confused and scared. It is hard to tell who the enemy is and what the rules of engagement for any given situation are. Frequently, he cannot tell the difference between friend and foe in country and finds himself increasingly terrified of his possible death and the deaths of those around him. To compound matters, his family has been less than supportive. Like many in the United States, he does not understand why we are there and what the goals are. Myers uses his storytelling abilities to clearly reflect many of the questions we have all asked ourselves since this invasion began. As he moves deeper and deeper into enemy territory, Birdy comes to understand what war really means, what he risks, and what he values.

Critical Evaluation- I have very much enjoyed this book. It is gritty and realistic without being overly graphic. The book has clearly avoided language realism in order to be sold to and taught in schools, but the novel is successful nevertheless. The book continues the story of the Perry family from his previous and very successful novel, Fallen
Angels, which will make it even more attractive to students who are familiar with Myers work.

Reader's Annotation- Like so many others, Robin Perry volunteers to serve his country after the 9/11 attacks, but is he ready for the realities of war? As he gets to know his team, Marla and Jonesy, how will Perry respond to what he discovers in Iraq?

Author Information- Walter Dean Myers follows up his highly acclaimed story Fallen Angels with another story about an equally confusing and difficult war. Myers is himself a veteran of the army and his understanding of military mentality is portrayed accurately here.

Curricular Ties- Current Events, Social Studies both American history and World history

Genre- Military/War novel

Book talking ideas- Is the war in Iraq justified?

Challenge issues- War and depictions of violence, some language

  1. Re-read the text to familiarize myself with the story
  2. Ask parents for their specific objections (they are required to file that with our school district)
  3. Review approved books list from California Department of Education for similar materials
  4. Review approaches from ALA


 

Interest Age- High school

Why I selected this piece- I'm always on the lookout for contemporary issues handled well by YA authors. Because I have several students who are entering the military, I thought this would be an interesting read to recommend to them. I am also studying Myers for my Author/Genre study